A family is choosing a messenger for its group chat. The son says Signal is the most secure, the mum says everyone is already on WhatsApp, the dad says Telegram is the most convenient. The argument goes round in circles because each is right in their own way.

How well a messenger protects you is not one word, "encryption". What matters is which chats are end-to-end encrypted, where history is stored and what the service knows about you. Below is a comparison based on each of the three's own documentation.

3 messengers
Compared only by their own documentation.
64 digits
In the key that can protect a WhatsApp backup.

Comparison

The main table


Telegram

WhatsApp

Signal

Private chats by default

Cloud chats, encrypted between app and server

End-to-end encrypted

End-to-end encrypted

End-to-end on request

A one-on-one secret chat

Not needed, always on

Not needed, always on

Group chats

Cloud chats, not end-to-end

End-to-end encrypted

End-to-end encrypted

Calls

End-to-end, group calls up to 200 people

End-to-end, including group calls

End-to-end

Where history lives

In Telegram's cloud, encrypted; secret chats on devices

On devices; backups in iCloud or Google Drive

On your devices

New device

Cloud chat history appears by itself

Through a backup

Through a transfer or Signal's own backup

Key verification

Emoji in calls, a key image in secret chats

A security code: QR or 60 digits

A safety number for each contact

Phone number

Needed to sign up, can be hidden; +888 numbers exist

Needed and serves as your identity

Needed to sign up; you can talk by username without showing it

Open source

Apps open, builds verifiable

No

Yes

What for what

Trade-offs

  • Telegram chose cloud convenience for ordinary chats: history is available on every device and is not lost with your phone. The price is that cloud chats are not end-to-end encrypted. Secret chats cover the private side, but you start them manually, and they live only on two devices.
  • WhatsApp encrypts everything end to end by default. Its weak spot is backups: you can protect them with a password or a 64-digit key, but that is a separate setting.
  • Signal encrypts everything and, by its own account, keeps a minimum about users: the account creation date and the last connection. History stays on your devices, and keeping it safe when you change phones is up to you.
Top: an ordinary Telegram chat through the cloud. Bottom: end-to-end encryption between devices.
Read left to right, top to bottom. Top: Telegram cloud chats. Bottom: end-to-end encryption in WhatsApp, Signal and Telegram secret chats. Check backups separately.

Scenarios

Which to choose

Task

What fits

Why

Messaging on phone, computer and tablet with full history

Telegram

Cloud chats everywhere, no backups

Channels, big groups, bots, mini apps

Telegram

This is its strong side

End-to-end encryption for every chat without settings

Signal or WhatsApp

On by default

The least data about you held by the service

Signal

By its own description it keeps almost nothing

One sensitive conversation inside Telegram

A Telegram secret chat

End-to-end encryption on two devices

You can move WhatsApp chats into Telegram with a built-in tool; how to do it and who sees the history is covered in "How to move WhatsApp chats to Telegram: private and group chats".

Questions

Does this mean Telegram is not secure?

No. All data in Telegram is encrypted in transit, and secret chats and calls are end-to-end encrypted. The difference is that ordinary chats are stored in the cloud for convenience. Details in "Is Telegram safe? Encryption, the cloud and what the company sees".

What matters more for security: the messenger or your habits?

Your habits. Any messenger is pointless if you hand over a login code or leave your phone without a screen lock. A cloud password, a passcode and checking your devices matter everywhere. For Telegram, every lock is collected in "Telegram security: everything in one place".

Can I use several messengers at once?

Yes. For example, Telegram for channels and work groups, and secret chats or Signal for sensitive conversations.


The three messengers give different answers to "where are my messages kept". Telegram keeps ordinary chats in the cloud for convenience and offers secret chats for privacy; WhatsApp and Signal encrypt everything end to end by default.

Choose for the task rather than by ranking. And whichever messenger wins the family argument, a cloud password and a locked phone will protect it better than any protocol.